WOOD-TV 8 | Group reveals top Mich pension payouts

Findings from TUA’s pension project on Grand Rapids, Michigan, are featured in the following video by WOOD-TV 8.

Updated: Tuesday, 06 Dec 2011, 8:07 PM EST
Published : Tuesday, 06 Dec 2011, 5:40 PM EST

  • By Anne Schieber

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) – A retired teacher in Michigan will receive $6 million in a pension payout, the highest government payout in the state, claims a taxpayer advocacy group.
Taxpayers United of America is researching and publishing top government pensions across the country and was in Grand Rapids Tuesday to release their state findings.
The group is highlighting government retirees getting a guaranteed pension through what’s known as a defined benefit program.
In Grand Rapids, the group claims, the highest annual pension being paid by the city is more than $96,000 per year. Based on a life expectancy of 85, that payout tops $3.4 million. That’s followed closely by payout among police and fire retirees – $3.3 million.
The top payout in Kent County is $2.5 million, and the next 24 pensions on each list all exceed $2 million.
“Our hope is to shed light on this issue,” said Christina Tobin, the VP of Taxpayers United of America. “Taxpayers see these names. They have a connection. This is my neighbor.”
The group also looked at pensions for judges, state workers and teachers.
Most government workers receive guaranteed pensions. In the local private sector, only 7% of workers get them, according to The Employers Association.
Defined benefit plans for government workers have been in place for decades, and were designed to make up for lower government salaries.
“That situation doesn’t exist today,” said the group’s Rae Ann McNeilly, adding government workers “are paid almost twice as much as those in the private sector, on the national level.”
County Administrator Daryl Delabbio told 24 Hour News 8 on Tuesday in an email statement that Kent County doesn’t offer retiree healthcare. Instead, he said, the county offers a monthly stipend of up to $350 depending on how long the retiree served the county.
Delabbio said that Kent County’s Other Post-Employment Benefit (OPEB) is lower than that of many other counties.
“For instance,” he pointed out, “Kent County OPEB liability is roughly 35-36 million dollars; Wayne County’s OPEB is over 800 million dollars.”
Delabbio also said that “Kent County’s pension system is managed very well, is funded appropriately, and we have taken steps over the past 18 months to modify pension contributions by employees and retirement eligibility to further contain our costs.”
City and county commissioners, the city manager and the state teacher’s union did not respond to a request for comment from 24 Hour News 8.

WLNS 6 | New Reports Reveals High Public Sector Pension Payouts

Findings from TUA’s pension project are featured in the following article by WLNS 6.

Most of us do our best to save for retirement, but a new report shows some in the public sector, state employees, state police officers and judges, have a golden payday when they reach their golden years.

New numbers made available through the Freedom of Information Act show retirement for public sector employees appears to be a very lucrative proposition.
Taxpayers United For America released the top pensions in the pubic sector in the area. One teacher who retired in 2008 will make about $6 million total, at $174,000 a year. One state police officer who retired in 2006 will earn about $3 million total at $88,000 a year, and one judge who retired this year will make about $3.5 million at an annual payout of $98,000.
The report assumes the individuals will retire at age 55 and collect money for 30 years.
“The real key is making sure all new government employees go into 401k. No more pension. 401k, [and] social security [is sufficient],” said Christina Tobin with Taxpayers United For America, “We’re also asking for them to put more into the system. 10% more if they don’t do anything. The government employees will get nothing, the system will collapse, we need pension reform in Michigan right away.”
To find out more click here.

Ingham and Eaton and Lansing, Oh My! Top Government Pensions Exposed!

LANSING–A report released today by Taxpayers United of America (TUA) reveals that retired Ingham and Eaton County, and Michigan state government employees are not only receiving lavish, gold-plated pensions, but that their pension payments, in many cases, are larger than some salaries in the private sector. Furthermore, over a normal lifetime, many of these government employees, when they retire, become pension millionaires.
“While Ingham and Eaton Counties stagnate with 10.4% and 9.0% unemployment; median home values of $140,000 and $155,000; and average annual wages of $49,000and $42,000, respectively, retired area government employees are enjoying lavish, gold-plated pensions that have made some of them pension millionaires,” said Christina Tobin, TUA Vice President.
Please click below to view:

“The city of Lansing responded to our Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request with invoices totaling more than $23,000 to retrieve the data.  Assistant City Attorney and FOIA Coordinator, Donald J. Kulhanek’s outrageous bill is tantamount to a refusal to release the pensions for Lansing?”
“Eaton and Inghan County retired government employees are doing much better than the average area worker in the private sector. Retired Eaton county government employee James Stewart receives an annual pension of $81,841. (Read more…)