ABC 7 Chicago | Emanuel changes speed-cameras plan before vote

Christina Tobin, TUA’s Vice President, was featured in a story from ABC 7 Chicago for her testimony against Chicago’s speed-camera ordinance. To see the video, click on the image below.
April 11, 2012 (CHICAGO) (WLS) —  Hours before a city council committee was expected to vote on Rahm  Emanuel’s controversial plan for speed cameras Wednesday, the mayor made  some tweaks to his proposal.
Mayor Emanuel wants to install speed cameras around schools and parks.
After listening to the complaints of some aldermen, the mayor offered some revisions Wednesday.
Initially under the plan, speeders caught driving between six and 10  miles per hour over the limit were set to get slapped with a $50 ticket,  but Emanuel changed the plan Wednesday to drop the fine to $35. Drivers  who exceed the limit by 11 miles per hour might still get fined $100.
Another changes would be that first time offenders will receive a warning.
The City Council’s committee on pedestrian and traffic safety held hearings on the speed camera plan Wednesday afternoon.
“A  pedestrian hit by a car at 20 miles per hour, the speed in the school  zone, has a 95 percent chance of living,” Klein told the City Council.   “That same person hit by a car traveling over 40 miles per hour has an  80 percent chance of dying.”
Emanuel says the camera plan is a matter of safety, but critics aren’t buying the data.
Christina Robin of Taxpayers United of America says the speed cameras are all about making money.
“These  are all lies,” Robin told ABC7.  “There is no facts or basis that the  cameras help the children or help safety. That’s a downright lie.  It is  like arguing that the earth is flat. It is not.”
If the cameras  will bring in revenue, some aldermen are concerned about how the money  will be spent.  Commissioner Klein admits that has not been worked out.
“We have no revenue projections and if there is revenue, the  mayor has been clear that it will be spent on public safety initiatives  to ensure safety passages around schools, to provide police protection  and surveillance around schools and parks,” said Klein.
Ald.  Scott Waguespack, who represents the 32nd Ward, has gathered his own  research about the speed cameras and the mayor’s plan to cover the city  with 360 of them.
“There are constituents who call and say, ‘I  want speed cameras around the schools. There are some, but 9 out of 10  have said, ‘No,'” said Waguespack.
According to Waguespack, the  thousands of speed bumps already in place around schools are doing a  good job of calming traffic.
According to a <a href=”http://www.suntimes.com/” target=”_blank”>Chicago Sun-Times</a> report, the City of Chicago has installed 10,000 speed bumps on city  streets and alleys since 2005. Many of them are located near schools and  parks, making it difficult for drivers to break the speed limit in the  spots where the mayor wants to use the cameras.
The mayor’s  office insists the speed cameras will help keep children safer,  stressing the plan is not a ploy to bring in revenue to the  cash-strapped city. Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn has already given the green  light to plan.
Waguespack says he is not sold.
“A lot  of people across the city are saying slow this thing down.  We don’t  need to blanket the entire city.  We can pick the places where people  are speeding,” he said.
The streets around Disney II Magnet  School on Chicago’s Northwest Side are covered with speed bumps.  Some  parents say they are enough. Others like Renee Linnemeyer say people  ignore them. She does not think the cameras would be an excessive  addition.
“Speeding is against the law. So, if that’s the way  they’re going to catch people doing it and make money for the city –the  city needs money,” Linnemeyer said.
After the committee votes  on the proposal, the recommendation will be considered by the full City  Council.  The aldermen have to sign off off on the plan before it can go  into effect.

Telemundo Chicago | Cobran fuerza las "cámaras de velocidad"

Christina Tobin, TUA’s Vice President, was featured in a story from Telemundo Chicago for her testimony against Chicago’s speed-camera ordinance. To see the video, click on the image below.

Una propuesta para instalar 300 camaras destinadas a medir la velocidad cerca de escuelas y parques alrededor de la ciudad, cobro fuerza hoy en el comite para la seguridad vehicular y de peatones en Chicago.

Los conductores que sean captados por estas cámaras excediendo el límite de velocidad entre seis y 10 millas por hora serán multados $35 dólares. Si se pasan de las 11 millas podrían pagar hasta $100.
La idea parece buena, pero no todos están de acuerdo. De hecho el alcalde Rahm Emmanuel tuvo que reducir el monto que originalmente se había propuesto para las multas y el horario en que funcionarán las cámaras para calmar los ánimos.
Por ejemplo Christina Tobin, vice presidenta de la Organización de Contribuyentes Unidos de América, dice que la ordenanza tiene como objetivo recaudar dinero para financiar un convaleciente programa de pensiones.
Los propulsores de la ley argumentan que otras ciudades en el país han reducido en un 70 por ciento las muertes a causa de conductores irresponsables por medio del uso de cámaras.
En Chicago un 40 por ciento de los accidentes con peatones son personas que huyen de la escena de un accidente. Esta cifra es el doble del promedio nacional.
Para la iniciativa este es solo el primer paso. Ahora pasará al Pleno del Concejo, pero allí, también se espera que sea aprobada.

Christina Tobin Testifies Against Proposed Chicago Speed-Trap Cameras, Receives News Coverage

View release as a PDF
CHICAGO–Christina Tobin, Vice President of Taxpayers United of America (TUA), testified against Chicago’s proposed speed-camera ordinance on Wednesday, April 11. Speaking before the Committee on Pedestrian and Traffic Safety in City Council Chambers at City Hall, Tobin urged the committee “To kill the proposal to add speed-cameras all over the city.”
Tobin made the following points:

  • Chicago politicians say speed-cameras will reduce juvenile pedestrian crashes and deaths, but, in reality, these speed-cameras would just be speed-trap cameras to fund city pensions. The proposal has nothing to do with safety. It’s all about money.
  • The newspaper Towson Patch reported that when Baltimore County officials rolled out a network of 15 speed cameras in school zones in 2010, they said the program’s success would be measured in two ways: less speeding and fewer accidents. While speeding was reduced, the report showed no decline in accidents in those zones.

Tobin pointed out that as early as 2008, the head of Mayor Daley’s pension reform commission recommended a plan in which newly-hired employees would be put in 401(k) plans favored by private industry instead of unsustainable pension plans. Tobin stressed that Chicago residents need tax relief, not new fines or new taxes, adding, “There is no need to bleed Chicago residents to death.”
“80% of city spending is for salaries & benefits. Most of the Speed Camera revenue will ultimately be used to fund city pensions. Unfunded pensions are the #1 budgetary problem in the United States.”
Tobin’s testimony received coverage from news outlets covering the hearing. Of particular note is video from ABC 7 and WGN TV.
The committee approved the ordinance 7-3. The full City Council will take up the ordinance next week, where Mayor Emanuel will need 26 votes to pass it.